Exit Buylist

We pay 30% more in store credit! Prices displayed are cash values for English cards in mint or near-mint condition. Our online buylist only covers Standard and Modern cards. If you’re looking to sell Legacy cards, foils, non-English cards, or a large collection, please drop by the store or email us.

Please review our buylist policies & information before submitting your buylist!

Most Wanted

Browse the Buylist

Modern Sets

Special Sets

Legacy Sets, Older Special Sets, and Foils

Our online buylist doesn't cover these sets yet. If you're interested in selling foils or cards from sets not listed above, please bring them into the store or email us for a quote!

Getting started with our buylist

  1. Find the card you want to sell using the search box above, or by browsing by set.
  2. Click the "Sell" button to add it to your buylist cart.
  3. When you're done adding cards, click the cart link at the top of the page. You can also edit quantities or remove cards from your cart on this page.
  4. Follow the checkout prompts to complete your buylist order.
  5. Wait for an email confirming that your buylist was accepted. This usually takes less than a day.
  6. Check the confirmation email for any changes to your buylist, and make sure your cards are sorted in the same order they are listed in the confirmation email.
  7. Bring your cards to EudoGames, or mail them to us.

Buylist details and policies

Please read the following information carefully before submitting your buylist order!


We offer payment by PayPal, Check, or Store Credit. Please note that PayPal may deduct a small fee if you choose to recieve payment via PayPal; refer to PayPal's fee schedule for more information.

We offer 30% more in Store Credit on all non-Bulk items. Store Credit can be used toward the purchase of anything we sell — including Magic singles, sealed product, and gaming accessories — as well as event entry fees. Store Credit never expires, so if you aren't ready to spend it, you can keep it for as long as you like.

Bulk Rates

We buy bulk cards! Bulk cards must be in English and in good condition. Payment for bulk cards is currently offered in Store Credit only. Bulk rates are based on card rarity:

Rare & Mythic:
$0.05 per card
$0.01 per card
$0.01 per 20 cards

Please note that we no longer buy Standard-legal cards in bulk.

Please contact us before mailing us your bulk cards!

Card Criteria

We only buy English cards. If we receive foreign cards in place of English cards, we reserve the right to discount their price by up to 50%, or return them to your at your expense.

Please double-check the condition of your cards. The prices listed on our buylist are for cards in Near Mint condition only. If we recieve cards in less than Near Mint condition, we reserve the right to discount their price up to 75%, or return them to you at your expense. See our card condition guide for details.

Please sort your cards to match the order shown in the confirmation email. If your cards arrive out of order, there may be delays in processing your buylist. In extreme cases, such as large buylists arriving in random order, we may assess a penalty of up to 10% of the final value, or return the entire order at your expense.

If we intend to discount the total value of your buylist by more than 15%, or return your cards to you, we will contact you first.

Mailing Guidelines

If you are sending your cards to us through the mail, please include a printed copy of your confirmation email with your cards so we can locate your order in our system and pay you in a timely fashion!

Package your cards securely to avoid damage during shipment. Do not use plastic bags or rubber bands! We prefer that you do not individually sleeve your cards, as we must unsleeve every card to check its condition.

Cards must be received within 7 days of the date your buylist was accepted. Cards arriving after this deadline may have their values adjusted to reflect our current buylist prices, or be returned to you at your expense.

We strongly recommend that you purchase tracking and insurance for your package. Occasionally things do get lost or damaged in the mail, and we cannot be responsible for postal errors.

Our mailing address is:

2154 University Ave
Berkeley, CA 94704-1026


Cards that are not in Near Mint condition, or are not in English, will have their value discounted or be returned to you at your expense. Please inspect your cards closely to make sure they meet our criteria before sending them!

If you are unsure about the condition of some of your cards, and would prefer to have any that are not graded at Near Mint to be returned to you at your expense, please include a physical note with your cards.

If we intend to discount the total value of your buylist by more than 15%, or return your cards to you, we will contact you first.